Yahoo Maps vs Google Maps: Yahoo getting better and better




Yahoo Maps BetaA few months ago I wrote a little rant about how none of the map websites accepted a single paste a of multi-line address, and how lame that was. I followed up with writing my own little hack to make it possible with Google Maps and Yahoo Maps.

Shortly after writing these blog posts, I was asked to do a User Interface presentation at one of the major search/maps companies in Sillicon Valley
. Part of my presentation included the Multi-line paste issue as an example of how simple problems with low-tech solutions can be overlooked and never addressed, and how testing a product differs from actually using a product. My hope with both the UI presentation and my blog posts was that the big map engines would add this simple yet overlooked feature.

Well, a few months ago I noticed that Yahoo Maps Beta was successfully accepting multi-line strings of text pasted into it, properly converting it to one line and adding the comma. Google Maps still chokes on multi-line pastes.

Great work Yahoo. Since it launched I've felt Yahoo Maps Beta was better than Google Maps, but improvements like this is why Yahoo is pulling ahead even further. It's excellent to see a big company paying attention to users and taking the time to implement the small details that make all the difference.

Update:

I got a comment from Matt Cutts pointing out that Google Maps should accept the multi-line paste, and he tried it in IE and it worked. I just tried it in IE and it indeed did work, however it did not work in Firefox (which is pretty much all I use, depsite the fact that it crashes all the time). I've not tried Safari yet.

So, it's cool that Google is listening and working on making it better, even if it's not fully compatible with Firefox yet. I still think Yahoo has an edge here since it worked in Firefox (but they're using Flash, and that's a whole different debate as to whether that's good or bad). Neither Yahoo nor Google have an affordance for it yet, which is why it took me so long to discover the change had been made, but that's okay. Hopefully as more people become familiar with the feature, it will spread as a cool trick.



Feedback - 3 responses

Displayed newest to oldest. Leave a comment.
Jimmy Leiderman wrote:   
Hi Hanford, would like to have the Multi-line Input for Map tool listed at my directory of Google Maps related resources. Feel free to drop by and submit the tool site to the "creation tools" category. Your blog would be a nice addition to the directory too.
Matt Cutts wrote:   
Hey, I'm an engineer at Google. I read your post about multi-line text a while ago and asked someone at Google about it back then. I was under the impression that multi-line cut/paste was working now.

I made a little text file at http://www.mattcutts.com/files/address.txt and cut and paste the last two lines in IE into http://maps.google.com/ and it looked like it accurately handled the multiline input correctly.

Could you check maps.google.com again? It's certainly possible that I've hacked my browser and forgot about it. For example, I used IE because in Firefox I used about:config to set editor.singleLine.pasteNewlines to 3 so that the browser does multiline paste by itself. But I thought that Google handled multi-line paste now.
Tom Iwanowicz wrote:   
I have to agree - although I haven't checked with new updates for their map service (beta).

I used Googles map service - but since the events on my site are user entered - they can get screwed up sometimes and Yahoo is VERY generous in figuring out what the actually meant.

Tom - PaMidstate Events & Entertainment
 

This site is mostly about

Video Game Design

User Interface Design

Creative & fun stuff

 

Your Host

I'm Hanford Lemoore. My parking skills are unparalleled.

I make things. From consumer electronics, to video games, to theme park attractions. Perhaps I can make things for you! Check out my portfolio.

When I'm not making things for other people, I'm usually experimenting.

 

Contact

Follow me on Twitter.

Message me on Facebook.

Email me using my contact form.

 

RSS 2.0

 

maquettegame.com

tikiroom.com

junkyardclubhouse.com

monolux.com

 

   


Copyright 2014 Hanford Lemoore | Blog | About | Portfolio | Contact
Powered by Olark